Brown Sugar Pop Tart Cookies Recipe

If you have a sweet tooth and adore the nostalgic charm of pop tarts but crave a homemade twist, these Brown Sugar Pop Tart Cookies are about to become your new favorite treat. Soft, buttery cookie layers hug a warm cinnamon-brown sugar filling that oozes with every bite, all topped off with a simple glaze and optional sprinkles for a playful finish. They perfectly combine classic flavors and comforting textures that remind me of childhood mornings but with all the fresh-baked goodness of a cookie. Trust me, once you try these, you’ll want to make them over and over again.

Ingredients You’ll Need

Keep it simple but essential when it comes to making these amazing Brown Sugar Pop Tart Cookies. Each ingredient plays a crucial role in building the flavor, softness, and that irresistible filling and glaze combo that makes these so special.

• Unsalted butter, 1 cup: Using unsalted butter lets you control the saltiness perfectly and adds richness to the cookies.
• Brown sugar, 1 cup (packed): This gives the dough a deep, molasses-like sweetness and keeps the cookies soft and chewy.
• Granulated sugar, 1/2 cup: Adds a touch of crispness and balances the brown sugar’s moisture.
• Large eggs, 2: These provide structure and help bind all the ingredients together.
• Vanilla extract, 1 teaspoon: A warm, fragrant note that elevates the entire cookie’s flavor.
• All-purpose flour, 3 cups: The base that gives the cookies their tender texture.
• Baking powder, 1 teaspoon: Helps the cookies rise just enough to stay light.
• Baking soda, 1/2 teaspoon: Works with the brown sugar to create that perfect crumb.
• Salt, 1/2 teaspoon: Enhances the sweetness and balances the flavor.
• Brown sugar for filling, 1 cup: This is the heart of the filling—sweet and caramel-y.
• Cinnamon, 1 tablespoon: Adds a warm, spicy kick that pairs wonderfully with brown sugar.
• Milk, 1/4 cup: Keeps the filling a little creamy and helps the cinnamon and sugar meld.
• Powdered sugar, 1 cup (for icing): This creates the sweet glaze that sets off these cookies perfectly.
• Milk, 1-2 tablespoons (for icing consistency): Use as needed to get the glaze just right—thick but pourable.
• Sprinkles (optional): Because a little decoration never hurts and adds a fun, festive touch.

How to Make Brown Sugar Pop Tart Cookies

Step 1: Preparing the Dough

Starting with the dough, this is where your cookies begin to come to life. Cream together the softened butter along with both the brown and granulated sugars until the mixture is fluffy and light—this gives the cookies their tender crumb. Adding eggs one at a time ensures your dough stays smooth and elastic. Finally, combine your dry ingredients separately and fold them in gently to avoid overmixing, which keeps your cookies perfectly tender instead of tough.

Step 2: Preparing the Filling

Mix the brown sugar and cinnamon to form a fragrant, sweet filling that will be the star of the show. Combining this with just a touch of milk makes the filling a little sticky and easy to spread, so it melts into the cookie beautifully while baking.

Step 3: Rolling Out the Dough

Divide the dough and roll it out on a lightly floured surface to about 1/4 inch thickness. Then cut the dough into rectangles—about 3 by 4 inches is perfect to mimic traditional pop tarts but feel free to tweak based on your mood. This shape makes assembling easier and ensures even baking. Rolling both portions this way preps everything for assembly without a fuss.

Step 4: Assembling the Brown Sugar Pop Tart Cookies

This step is where you’ll really see your cookie dreams take shape. Place a spoonful of the cinnamon-brown sugar mixture in the center of a dough rectangle and cover with a second one. Seal the edges firmly to keep the filling inside during baking, using a fork for a cute crimped look if you want that charming, homemade feel. Lining the assembled cookies spaced apart on a parchment-lined baking sheet ensures they bake evenly and don’t stick together.

Step 5: Baking the Cookies

Slide your tray into a preheated 350°F oven and bake for 12 to 15 minutes until the edges develop that perfect golden hue. The scent is enchanting and means these cookies are nearly ready to enjoy. Let them cool just enough so you can handle them before moving on to icing.

How to Serve Brown Sugar Pop Tart Cookies

Garnishes

While the simple glaze already dresses these cookies beautifully, adding sprinkles on top can create a playful look that’s perfect for parties or a little everyday fun. You can also try a pinch of flaky sea salt right after glazing to add a sophisticated sweet-salty contrast.

Side Dishes

The cozy flavors of these cookies pair wonderfully with a glass of cold milk or a warm cup of chai tea or coffee. The spices and sweetness meld perfectly with those beloved beverages, making snack time a mini celebration anytime you want.

Creative Ways to Present

Try stacking your Brown Sugar Pop Tart Cookies on a pretty plate with a drizzle of extra glaze around them, or arrange them in a tin lined with parchment for gifting. You can even sneak in some chopped nuts in the filling or drizzle melted chocolate on top for a special twist that’ll impress friends and family alike.

Make Ahead and Storage

Storing Leftovers

To keep your Brown Sugar Pop Tart Cookies fresh, store them in an airtight container at room temperature for up to 4 days. This keeps the cookie soft and the filling moist—no need to worry about them drying out too fast.

Freezing

If you want to enjoy these at a later date, freeze the unbaked assembled cookies on a baking sheet first, then transfer them to a freezer-safe bag. They’ll keep for up to 3 months. When you’re ready to bake, pop them straight into the oven—just add a couple of extra minutes to the baking time!

Reheating

For freshly baked warm cookies, a quick 10-15 second zap in the microwave softens things up beautifully. Or warm them gently in a 300°F oven for about 5 minutes to revive that just-baked goodness. Perfect when you want a cozy afternoon pick-me-up.

FAQs

Can I use light brown sugar instead of dark brown sugar?

Absolutely! Light brown sugar will work just fine and yield a subtly lighter molasses flavor. The cookies will still be rich and delicious.

What if I don’t have cinnamon on hand?

You can swap cinnamon for pumpkin pie spice or even nutmeg for a different but still warmly spiced filling. Or keep it simple with just brown sugar, though you’ll miss that signature cinnamon warmth.

Can I make these gluten-free?

Yes, but you’ll want to substitute the all-purpose flour with a gluten-free blend designed for baking. Make sure to pick one with xanthan gum or add it separately to maintain the right texture.

Do I have to add icing and sprinkles?

Not at all. The cookies themselves are delicious on their own. The glaze adds sweetness and shine, while sprinkles add fun and color. Feel free to customize to your taste!

How long do these cookies last?

When stored properly in an airtight container, Brown Sugar Pop Tart Cookies remain tasty for up to 4 days at room temperature. Beyond that, they might dry out unless frozen.

Final Thoughts

I cannot recommend these Brown Sugar Pop Tart Cookies enough if you’re craving something that feels nostalgic yet fresh and homemade. They bake up soft, buttery, and packed with the all-time favorite cinnamon-brown sugar filling that makes your kitchen smell amazing. Plus, they’re fun to assemble and perfect for sharing with loved ones or treating yourself anytime. Give these a go—you might just find your new ultimate comfort cookie!

Print